One Request Away No. 19 Streak 0 Solved 0 of 27

Points that arrive before they leave

Medium Business Logic 15 Sep 2026 Solved by 2

Scenario

Silverlink is a coalition loyalty scheme. Members can hold more than one account, and points can be moved between accounts they own.

You hold two: 88214009 with 41,000 points on it, and 90117442 with 2,500. This is the request the transfer screen sends.

Transfers are free, instant, and capped only by the balance on the sending account.

One change to this request triggers the vulnerability. The challenge is to use your security intuition to work out what to change. Find the value the server shouldn’t trust, change it, and send it. The response tells you whether you were right.

Request Tap any part of it
/// HTTP/1.1
Host:
Content-Type:
Cookie: slk_session=
from=&to=&points=
No change — send it as it stands
Response

  • 01 What the server believed

    “A transfer moves value between two records, so the two records are different.”

  • 02 The fix

    Reject a transfer where the source and destination are the same account, which is the cheap fix and the one to ship first. Then correct the underlying operation: apply both sides in one transaction with a conditional update on the balance, or express the debit and credit as relative adjustments rather than writes of a value read earlier, so that two updates to one row compose instead of overwriting.

  • 03 Where else to look for this

    Anywhere one operation reads and writes two records that the caller names: transfers between accounts, moving stock between locations, reassigning an item from one owner to another, merging two records, swapping two positions. The check is to put the same identifier on both sides and see whether anything objects, then look at whether the totals still add up.

The series

Every drill 27

One Request Away is a daily series of challenges. They’re like code review, but for HTTP requests: in each one you’re one request away from triggering a vulnerability, and your goal is to identify what you need to change.

Do not stop here

A drill is one request.
A lab is the whole app.

Uphack labs are believable products with one realistic flaw buried in an ordinary feature. Same instinct, nothing highlighted — you get a running application and have to find it yourself.

Browse the labs
Registration is open Closes today

Turn the instinct into practice.

Drills are free and stay that way. The labs put the same reasoning against a whole application, and members get all of them. Registration is open until Saturday 19 September.

Create your account

Already a member? Sign in